NerdWallet, Insurify, and EverQuote stand out as the best car insurance comparison sites for finding fast, reliable quotes across the best auto insurance companies.
Our Top 10 Picks: Best Car Insurance Comparison Sites
Comparison SiteOverall RankTrust ScoreCustomer RatingFounded InMonthly UsersDomain AuthorityGlobal Rank
#1Very High3.7 / 5200910M+811.4K
#2High4.8 / 520132.6M+5915.4K
#3High1.3 / 520113.2M+6517.9K
#4High4.5 / 520121.5M+6228.6K
#5High4.7 / 520061.8M+5632.5K
#6Moderate1.6 / 520121.1M+3939.6K
#7High4.6 / 52013370K+5188.4K
#8High4.7 / 52014440K+70130K
#9High4.0 / 52016300K+58240K
#10High3.5 / 52016100K+39518K
Compare RatesStart Now →
We evaluated each platform based on monthly traffic volume, customer ratings, whether quotes are shown instantly on-site or through redirection, the number and variety of insurers included, and the quality of filtering tools.
Things to Remember NerdWallet ranks #1 with 10 million monthly users and strong financial tools Insurify shows real-time quotes with filters and no spam, great for budget shoppers EverQuote connects high-risk drivers to more carriers, but redirects for quotesWhile we excluded AutoInsurance.org to keep the rankings unbiased, it’s still the most efficient and accurate site for comparing auto insurance quotes. Use our free quote comparison tool to find the top providers in your area – all in under two minutes.
How Car Insurance Comparison Tools Help You Easily Compare QuotesCar insurance comparison tools let you enter basic details like your ZIP code, vehicle, and coverage needs to view prices from multiple companies. Some tools show quotes instantly, while others require a few extra steps, but all aim to simplify the process of shopping for coverage.
Insurance Comparison Site Features
Comparison SiteSings PotentialAnnual SingsQuote TimeCustomer SatisfactionProviders Compared
40%$5402 minutes98%80+
25%$3803 minutes89%30+
30%$4103 minutes90%40+
20%$3203 minutes88%25+
30%$4202 minutes94%120+
15%$2754 minutes86%20+
20%$3005 minutes89%700+
15%$2805 minutes87%12+
20%$3504 minutes88%25+
25%$3902 minutes90%35+
25%$4003 minutes91%100+
Compare RatesStart Now →
The best auto insurance comparison sites don’t just help you se — they make it easier to get quotes from top insurers in one place. But each site works a little differently. Some show quotes on the site, while others redirect you or send your information to agents (Read More: How to Get an Auto Insurance Quote Without Giving Personal Information).
Below, we break down how NerdWallet, Insurify, and EverQuote help you compare quotes and how these top car insurance comparison sites rank based on trust, online authority, and user reach.
NerdWalletNerdWallet is ideal for drivers who want to compare car insurance alongside other financial tools. Founded in 2009, it has a DA of 81, a global rank of 1,400, and draws over 10 million visitors monthly. While not insurance-specific, it’s trusted for its in-depth guides and helpful quote comparisons, especially for users who want a broader financial view.
NerdWallet helps drivers compare insurance by guiding them through a step-by-step quote process. To get started, you’ll enter your ZIP code, vehicle details, age, and basic driver information, including your driving record and insurance history.
Unlike dedicated insurance comparison platforms, NerdWallet typically redirects users to insurer websites to complete the quote. This means you won’t always see prices directly on NerdWallet’s site. It’s a helpful tool if you’re researching providers and reading advice, but it’s less efficient for side-by-side quote comparisons.
Learn More: How to Choose an Auto Insurance Company
InsurifyInsurify is best for quick, private quote comparisons with no redirects or phone number required. Launched in 2013, it delivers real-time results in under two minutes. With a DA of 59 and global rank of 15,400, it’s a forite among budget-conscious drivers looking for fast, personalized rates without the spam.
Insurify is designed specifically for users to get free online auto insurance quotes. Provide ZIP code, age, driving history, coverage preferences, and vehicle information, including make and model.
You’ll also need to enter an email address, but no phone number is required. Within minutes, Insurify displays real-time quotes directly on the site from top insurers, allowing users to compare prices and coverage in a clean, side-by-side layout without being redirected.
EverQuoteEverQuote has a high trust score, a domain authority of 65, and a global rank of 17,900. While it maintains strong web visibility and high traffic, its business model leans more toward lead generation than full-service quote comparison. That’s why it’s better suited for users looking for a car insurance agent and who prefer personal assistance over instant quote results.
EverQuote collects your ZIP code, vehicle and driver information, and coverage preferences. Unlike Insurify, you must enter both your email and phone number, which are then shared with agents and insurance partners.
Instead of showing prices directly on the site, EverQuote typically redirects users to external websites or prompts follow-up contact from providers. As a result, many users experience frequent calls or emails after using the platform, and direct quote comparison is limited.
Read More: How to Evaluate Auto Insurance Quotes
Free Auto Insurance ComparisonEnter your ZIP code below to view companies that he cheap auto insurance rates.
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Many drivers he shared their experiences using the best car insurance comparison sites, and reviews show what works well and what doesn’t.
NerdWallet has a 3.7 out of 5 rating on Trustpilot. Users appreciate its comprehensive financial tools and resources. However, some mention that obtaining auto insurance quotes can involve multiple steps, making the process less streamlined compared to more specialized platforms.
Third-Party Customer Ratings for Top Car Insurance Comparison Sites
Site
A+NA3.7 / 5
2K+ reviews
B+3.8 / 5
130+ reviews4.8 / 5
5K+ reviews
B3.72 / 5
580+ reviews1.3 / 5
45+ reviews
A-3.86 / 5
400+ reviews4.5 / 5
800+ reviews
A+3.85 / 5
630+ reviews4.7 / 5
580+ reviews
A+NA1.6 / 5
20+ reviews
A+3.95 / 5
1.2K+ reviews4.7 / 5
70+ reviews
ANA4.7 / 5
5.9K+ reviews
NANA4.0 / 5
5 reviews
A+NA4.0 / 5
80K+ reviews
Compare RatesStart Now →
Insurify is one of the top-rated options, with a 4.8 out of 5 score. People like that it’s easy to use, gives fast results, and doesn’t flood them with spam calls or emails. Some Reddit users say Insurify ge them real quotes from top insurance companies in just a few minutes.
Is insurify legit? byu/leadarla inInsurance
The Zebra also has great reviews, earning a 4.5 out of 5. Users like its clean layout and how simple it is to see quotes side-by-side. Even first-time shoppers say it’s easy to understand. Policygenius and Compare.com also do well with users who want to bundle car and home insurance, and they offer helpful tips while you shop.
Car insurance byu/ExplanationOdd2184 inCar_Insurance_Help
On the other hand, EverQuote gets a low 1.3 out of 5 rating, and many people complain about getting too many phone calls after using the site.
Choose comparison sites with real-time quotes, strong filters, and no phone number required to se time and find the best rate.
Michelle Robbins Licensed Insurance Agent
SmartFinancial has similar problems, with a 1.6 rating and reports of limited quote options and follow-ups from salespeople. Get fully informed through our guide on how to find affordable auto insurance rates online.
Why Uninsured Rates Matter When Using Comparison SitesCar insurance comparison sites are especially valuable in states with high uninsured motorist rates, where choosing the right coverage is critical. If you live in one of the states below, you pay more for auto insurance to account for the risk of uninsured drivers.
Uninsured Motorist Percentage by State
StateRankUM Percentage Washington#125.2% New Mexico#224.9% Mississippi#322.2% Tennessee#420.9% Michigan#519.6% Kentucky#618.7% Georgia#718.1% Delaware#818.1% Colorado#917.5% Ohio#1017.1% Compare RatesStart Now →Washington, D.C. leads with more than 25% of drivers uninsured, followed by New Mexico and Mississippi. Even states like Michigan and Tennessee show significant risk. Start comparing the best uninsured and underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage to find affordable coverage.
By using car insurance comparison sites, drivers in these areas can easily find policies that include uninsured motorist protection and compare prices across multiple providers to get the best deal.
How Often People Shop Around for Auto InsuranceMany drivers turn to the best car insurance comparison sites to shop for affordable coverage, but how often they do varies by age group. Millennials are the most active, with 20% using comparison sites every year to find better rates.
While some drivers revisit their options every 2–3 years, others rarely or never compare quotes — only 18% of Baby Boomers, 15% of Gen Z, and only 12% of Gen X.
Experience with car insurance comparison tools? byu/Theresbeerinthefridg inpersonalfinance
Why is it so hard to find cheap auto insurance? You could be paying too much for car insurance if you aren’t comparing quotes online. Using the best auto insurance comparison sites regularly can help drivers oid overpaying and ensure they get the best coverage.
Need insurance for a short time⏰? Check out our list of the top 10 cheapest insurance providers for temporary 🗓️coverage👉: https://t.co/n4sy1wZVsX pic.twitter.com/OYkLlefvq2
— AutoInsurance.org (@AutoInsurance) March 30, 2025
We didn’t include AutoInsurance.org in the rankings to stay fair, but many drivers say it’s the easiest and most reliable way to compare auto insurance quotes online. We help drivers se up to 40% more on erage than most competitors – enter your ZIP code to compare rates from the top providers near you.
Free Auto Insurance ComparisonEnter your ZIP code below to view companies that he cheap auto insurance rates.
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Our unbiased review found that NerdWallet, Insurify, and EverQuote he the best car insurance comparison tools for fast, real-time quotes. See why we chose each platform here:
#1 – NerdWallet Pros Helpful Tools: NerdWallet includes budget calculators, insurance explainers, and side-by-side comparisons to help users understand what they’re buying. Multi-Product Platform: You can compare auto insurance alongside credit cards, loans, and more in one place. High Authority: With over 10M+ monthly users, a DA of 81, and global rank of 1.4K, it’s one of the most trusted financial websites online. Get more insights in our NerdWallet review. Cons Moderate Focus on Insurance: Since the site covers many financial topics, users may he to dig through unrelated content to find quotes. Average User Reviews: A 3.7/5 rating reflects some user concerns about limited on-site quote functionality. #2 – Insurify Pros Real-Time Quotes: Insurify displays live quotes on-site, often within 2 minutes, with no phone number required. Highly Rated: With a 4.8/5 customer score, it’s known for accuracy, speed, and ease of use. Growing Reputation: Backed by 2.6M+ monthly users, a DA of 59, and global rank of 15.4K. Check out our Insurify auto insurance review to learn more. Cons Smaller Reach: This site gets less traffic than NerdWallet or EverQuote, so fewer users may sometimes mean fewer carriers. Not All Providers: Some big insurance companies may not appear on Insurify sites depending on your location. Free Auto Insurance ComparisonEnter your ZIP code below to view companies that he cheap auto insurance rates.
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that he cheap auto insurance rates.
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that he cheap auto insurance rates.
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Yes, comparison sites often help drivers find cheaper car insurance by allowing them to compare quotes from multiple companies in one place.
Read More: Best Auto Insurance Companies for Multiple Vehicles
What is the best insurance comparison site?NerdWallet, Insurify, and EverQuote top our unbiased rankings—but many drivers say AutoInsurance.org is truly the best for comparing quotes quickly and privately. Enter your ZIP code to get personalized insurance quotes tailored to your needs and budget.
What is the best way to comparison shop for car insurance?Enter your information on multiple trusted comparison sites like Insurify or AutoInsurance.org to view real quotes side by side and identify the best deal. AutoInsurance.org offers access to over 60 top-rated providers, which is more than most other comparison platforms. Enter your ZIP code to start comparing auto insurance for free.
Who has the best car insurance?The best car insurance depends on your needs, but top-rated companies often include State Farm, Geico, and Progressive—use comparison sites to find the best rate for you.
Read More: Why You Should Get Multiple Auto Insurance Quotes
Are quote results accurate on auto insurance comparison sites?Accuracy depends on the platform. Sites like AutoInsurance.org, Insurify, and Compare.com are known for providing upfront quotes that closely match what insurers actually charge.
Who typically has the cheapest car insurance?Drivers with clean records, good credit, and safe cars often get the lowest rates; regional companies and usage-based insurance may also offer cheaper options.
Is it cheaper to buy insurance directly from an insurance company?Not always—comparison sites often find lower rates by showing offers from multiple companies, some of which aren’t easily accessible directly.
Read More: How to Get a Quote From an Auto Insurance Company
Is NerdWallet legit for car insurance?Yes, NerdWallet is a trusted platform with strong online authority, though it usually redirects users to other sites for quote completion.
Does Costco offer car insurance?Costco partners with CONNECT by American Family Insurance to offer members exclusive auto insurance discounts and benefits.
Read More: What are the recommended auto insurance coverage levels?
How can I negotiate lower car insurance rates?Ask your provider about discounts, raise your deductible, improve your credit score, or use a comparison site to find a better rate, and use it as leverage.
Read more: What is a good deductible for auto insurance?
How do I choose the right car insurance company?Look for a provider with strong financial ratings, positive customer reviews, fair claims handling, and competitive pricing through quote comparison sites.
Read More: How to Manage Your Auto Insurance Policy
Which car insurance comparison site is the cheapest?Sites like Insurify and Compare.com are known for accurate real-time quotes, but AutoInsurance.org is often the fastest and most reliable for finding low rates with no spam.
Why is my car insurance so high with a clean record?High rates can be caused by factors like your ZIP code, vehicle type, credit score, or recent claims—even if your driving record is clean. Read more: How Auto Insurance Companies Check Driving Records
Why should you comparison shop before buying insurance?Rates can vary widely between companies for the same coverage, so comparing quotes helps ensure you don’t overpay.
Is Compare.com legit?Yes, Compare.com is a legitimate insurance comparison site with a strong reputation and a 4.6/5 customer rating for quote accuracy and transparency.
How can I pay less for my car insurance?Compare rates online, ask for discounts, bundle policies, choose higher auto insurance deductibles, and consider usage-based insurance if you drive less.
Can credit score impact insurance rates?Yes, in most states, insurers use credit-based insurance scores to help determine your premium—better credit can mean lower rates (Read more: How Credit Scores Affect Auto Insurance Rates).
GetJerry Review for 2025 (Valid Insurance Quotes?)Finder.com Review for 2025 (Legit Insurance Quotes?) Free Auto Insurance ComparisonEnter your ZIP code below to view companies that he cheap auto insurance rates.
Secured with SHA-256 Encryption
Written by:
Rachel Bodine
Feature Writer
Rachel Bodine graduated from college with a BA in English. She has since worked as a Feature Writer in the insurance industry and gained a deep knowledge of state and countrywide insurance laws and rates. Her research and writing focus on helping readers understand their insurance coverage and how to find sings. Her expert advice on insurance has been featured on sites like PhotoEnforced, All...
Full Bio → Written by Rachel BodineFeature Writer
Reviewed by:
Justin Wright
Licensed Insurance Agent
Justin Wright has been a licensed insurance broker for over 9 years. After graduating from Southeastern Seminary with a Masters in Philosophy, Justin started his career as a professor, teaching Philosophy and Ethics. Later, Justin obtained both his Property & Casualty license and his Life and Health license and began working for State Farm and Allstate. In 2020, Justin began working as an i...
Full Bio → Reviewed by Justin WrightLicensed Insurance Agent
Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.